Menu

Traditional VS Alternative Medicine: Americas Weigh In

Americans and especially African Americans have had a long history of home remedy use. In fact, slavery and segregation prevented African Americans from seeking traditional medical care for years. Thus, leaving black people with illnesses that had to be treated alternatively.

With no other choices, they would formulate their own alternates to medicine with home remedies that were essential in their survival. Many still use these same tactics in today’s modern society, as the medical world plays catch-up to the genetic differences in races and how medical care correlates.

According to a new government report, Americans spend a good chunk of their health care dollars on alternative medicine, such as acupuncture, yoga, chiropractic care and natural supplements.

Featured on BlackDoctor

In fact, they paid more than $30 billion out of pocket in 2012 on chiropractors and other complementary health practitioners, as well as supplements and other forms of alternative medicine.

“Substantial numbers of Americans spent billions of dollars out-of-pocket on these approaches — an indication that users believe enough in the value of these approaches to pay for

them,” said study co-author Richard Nahin.
He is lead epidemiologist at the U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.

Expenditures in 2012 included:
– $14.7 billion out-of-pocket on visits to complementary practitioners such as chiropractors, yoga instructors, acupuncturists or massage therapists — nearly 30 percent of what people spent on traditional medical services.
– $12.8 billion on natural product supplements, which was about one-quarter of what people spent on prescription drugs.
– $2.7 billion on books, CDs, videos and other self-help materials related to complementary health.

Overall, spending on complementary medicine amounted to just over 9 percent of out-of-pocket health care expenditures and about 1 percent of all money spent on health care in the United States, the researchers found.
Most of this alternative health care is being used by adults, not children, the report found. The researchers said about $28 billion was spent on adults, compared with just $1.9 billion for children.

Even people with lower incomes spend quite a bit on complementary medicine, according to the report published June 22 in the National Health Statistics Reports.

 

Nahin and his colleagues found that families making less than

$25,000 a year spent, on average, $314 out-of-pocket on visits to complementary health practitioners in 2012, and an average $389 on natural supplements.

“That’s telling us that even people with low incomes are willing to spend a substantial amount on these products and interventions,” Nahin said.

Families earning much higher incomes – $100,000 or more a year – spent an average of $518 on complementary practitioners and an average of $377 on supplements, the findings showed.

Other data suggests that there are trends within complementary medicine regarding the popularity of different approaches.

For example, Nahin explained, the use of yoga has increased dramatically, while chiropractic care and massage therapy has tended to remain level.

“Yoga is going up because

it’s more accepted in the culture, and it’s being used for lifestyle changes and as a form of low-impact exercise,” Nahin said.

But while people use yoga to promote wellness and well-being, they use chiropractic care and acupuncture as a treatment for a medical condition, most often chronic pain, he said.

“If you look at data on back pain across the last 10 years, it’s been fairly flat,” Nahin said. “It hasn’t changed, so perhaps use of these types of practitioners that treat back pain wouldn’t change.”

While it remains a multi-billion dollar industry, the use of natural supplements actually has decreased a bit, Nahin said, possibly due to increased attention from health researchers regarding these products.

Sales of fish oil supplements have

increased fourfold since 2002, based on studies showing the heart health benefits of omega 3 fatty acids, Nahin pointed out. However, research that found no substantial benefit from echinacea and ginkgo biloba has likely helped drive down sales of those particular supplements.

According to Stephanie Romanoff, communications director for the Academy of Integrative Health & Medicine, consumer demand for complementary medicine has caused more researchers to look into how well these approaches work, which in turn has provided consumers with better information.

“Integrative medicine is not going to have the same funding as pharmaceuticals do, but because of the consumer demand and increased interest from academia and our national government in integrative medicine and health, there has been an increase in research,” Romanoff said. “And increasingly, there’s more research validating the value of these approaches.”

People interested in trying chiropractic, acupuncture or some other form of complementary medicine should talk about it with their doctor, and make sure there is clear coordination between their primary care physician and their complementary medicine providers, Romanoff said.

“If someone is taking supplements or if they are seeing a different type of clinician, sometimes they don’t want to talk with their primary care medical doctor about it because they might feel self-conscious,” she said. “It’s absolutely critical that patients have those conversations and tell their doctors about the different types of care they’re receiving, and demand that there is coordination.”

Your doctor might even be able to point you to a properly accredited provider, particularly if your doctor is board-certified in integrative medicine, Romanoff added.

“Ask your primary care doctor for recommendations. That’s how I find many of my best clinicians,” she said.
Alternative medicine goes beyond just yoga and a few vitamins. Much of what is now categorized as alternative medicine was developed as an independent, complete medical system.

And for African Americans, that was rooted in African traditions that included herbal remedies, root medicines, and prayer. It was developed long before biomedicine and the use of scientific methods. Whether Americans decide to pop more ginger supplements or go to Bikram yoga, we’re glad to see the spike in this new health-conscious era.

 

SOURCES:
Richard Nahin, Ph.D., MPH, lead epidemiologist, U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health; Stephanie Romanoff, communications director, Academy of Integrative Health & Medicine; June 22, 2016, National Health Statistics Reports

Stephanie D. Taylor, Assistant Professor, College of Pharmacy, University of Michigan; Eddie L. Boyd, Associate Professor, College of Pharmacy, University of Michigan; Leslie A. Shimp, Associate Professor, College of Pharmacy, University of Michigan; 1998, Research Center For Group Dynamics of University of Michigan

SHARE
Related Stories
Answer the question below

Gout Survey

People with gout often have sudden, painful flares of joint swelling and redness. How many gout flares have you experienced in the last 12 months?
Have you ever received intravenous medicine for your gout?

Get our Weekly Newsletter

Stay informed on the latest breakthroughs in family health and wellness. Sign up today!

By subscribing, you consent to receive emails from BlackDoctor.com. You may unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy & Terms of Service.

More from BlackDoctor

Where Culture Meets Care

BlackDoctor is the world’s largest and most comprehensive online health resource specifically for the Black community. BlackDoctor understands that the uniqueness of Black culture - our heritage and our traditions - plays a role in our health. BlackDoctor gives you access to innovative new approaches to the health information you need in everyday language so you can break through the disparities, gain control and live your life to its fullest.
×

Download PDF

Enter your name and email to receive the download link.

BlackDoctor AI Search
✦ AI Search Disclaimer
This AI-powered search tool helps you find relevant health articles from the BlackDoctor.org archive. Please keep the following in mind:
✦ For Informational Purposes Only
The information provided through this AI search is for general educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
✦ Always Consult a Healthcare Provider
Never disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking it because of something you have read through this search tool. If you have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 immediately.
✦ AI Limitations
This search tool uses artificial intelligence to help match your queries with articles in our archive. While we strive for accuracy, AI-generated results may occasionally be incomplete, outdated, or not fully relevant to your specific situation.
✦ No Doctor-Patient Relationship
Using this search tool does not create a doctor-patient relationship between you and BlackDoctor.org or any healthcare provider.
Explore over 35,000 articles and videos across black health, wellness, lifestyle and culture
Full AI Search Experience >